11 Mar GamingLawPills #34: Gaming loot boxes reviewed in Poland and in Australia
GamingLawPills brings updates on the controversial legal regime of gaming loot boxes in Poland and in Australia with different outcomes.
Loot boxes are NOT gambling in Poland
The Polish Ministry of Finance made an announcement according to which loot boxes are not to be considered gambling following an analysis of the country’s gambling legislation. Poland’s statement comes despite the decision to follow the promise of other European regulators to address the “blurred lines” between video game loot boxes and gambling.
In his statement the ministry stated that “the element of randomness alone in a given undertaking does not determine the gambling character of a given game. In practice, there can be many undertakings which partially have a gambling character, but do not constitute gambling.”
The Polish government acknowledged that loot boxes are recognised as gambling in other jurisdictions, but argued that such decisions “depend to a large extent on the legislation that is binding in a given jurisdiction” and the definition of gambling differs across Europe.
As a result, much of the legal battle surrounding loot boxes and regarding the categorization of loot boxes as gambling involve the concepts of performance of a purchase with real money and the transferability of awarded items.
Gaming loot boxes under the radar in Australia
The Australian government will ignore a Senate committee’s recommendation to launch a comprehensive multi-agency review of the impact of loot boxes in video games. This decision follows the announcement of the Australian Senate Environment and Communications References Committee that had previously advised the Australian Government to undertake a comprehensive review of loot boxes within video games.
In its response, the federal government cited the lack of a “robust evidence base” affirming also that “developing an evidence-based regulatory approach to mitigate against any harms is challenging until further research is complete“. According to the statement, the Australian government noted that the video game industry is acting to protect consumers in the absence of a specific framework “taking steps to remove loot boxes from games or choosing to release new games without loot boxes“.
Doubts over the legal status of gaming loot boxes and other chance-based items are also reflected in the statements of the Australian regulator for online gambling (ACMA) which has asked for an assessment of loot boxes on a case-by-case basis
I am Vincenzo Giuffrè, you can drop me a line @ [email protected] and read the previous issues of GamingLawPills here. Also don’t forget to try Prisca, our GDPR chatbot described HERE and stay tuned and register to our newsletter!